I think that if we look at the New Covenant as [b]new relative to the Mosaic Covenant rather than as "spiritual and eternal instead of national/political and temporal," Jeremiah 31:31-34 means something much different. It fact, it changes Point Three above (on the RPW) by explicitly commanding that the sign of the Covenant be applied to children! drop

I've been back and forth on this myself over the months and years since we left a straying PCA church and ended up in a "Reformed Baptist" church where Mrs. Robin and I attend and participate. Asked whether I'm paedo or credo, I truly can't say anymore, but I definitely lean towards paedobaptist because of the Scriptures and Covenants taken as a whole.