Wesley actually strikes me as being kind of mixed up. His Arminianism had ostensibly (I actually haven't studied much about him) moved far from that of Aminius just like everybody else's did. But this odd Calvinism keeps sneaking up in his hymns- "And Can it Be" isn't the only one. Someone has said that everybody is a Calvinist when they pray. I'd add when they write hymns, too.

(Latin phrase goes here.)