Sojourner,

Please clarify for me

1) whether you believe that Cain had anything that God could call gratitude in his heart at the time of his offering, and

2) how "his belief in God as Lord of the universe and dispenser of secular blessings" differs from the belief shared by the demons, and

3) in light of the above, how his offering could be reckoned a "gratitude offering" at all?

In Christ,
Paul S