The Highway Forums General Discussion Theology Discussion Forum The Sabbath

Thank you, Pilgrim. Absolutely right! I've been involved on the 'other forum' mentioned by Tom, and we've been bombarded with selective quotes from Luther and Calvin. 'To the law and to the Testimony!'

Also, the truth is not established by 'It is written,' but by 'It is written again' (Matt 3:6-7 ). Even the devil can pull a text out of context and use it to his purpose. Scripture must be established by Scripture.

Steve

Thank you for your 'review of the review!' As I said, I really don't understand the implications of Gaffin's view or even Nathan's review of Gaffin's view. I have no working understanding of the controversy regarding Calvin's view of the Sabbath, let alone Calvin's view of the Sabbath itself! I just thought of this thread when I read it and thought it might be of interest to the participants of this thread.

I DO, however, agree 100% with your list of things to be remembered!

Actually, the issue is quite simple... There are those today who reject the historic Reformed view of the Sabbath as stated in the Westminster Standards, the LBCF, Savoy, and other confessions, i.e., the Sabbath is the Fourth Commandment which is perpetually binding upon all men and especially believers albeit the day was changed to the first day of the week, aka: the Lord's Day.

In this particular case, Gaffin and others are maintaining that "true" Calvinism, i.e., that which originated with Calvin and the other magisterial Reformers was not the same as the view later espoused by the Puritans. Thus, those who adhere to the formulation of Sabbatarianism from the WCF, etc., are in error and not embracing historic Calvinism. Thus Gaffin and others attempt to show that Calvin's view was different and secondly it is to be preferred over the Puritan view. Some go so far as to claim that Calvin actually bowled on Sunday. It is truly amazing how far some will go to justify their rejection of the Fourth Commandment.

Even if it were true that Calvin held to a libertarian view of the Sabbath or even if he rejected it outright, which is certainly not the case, John Calvin isn't the "standard" which a Christian should look to for matters of doctrine or practice. Fortunately, men such as Stuart Lauer have challenged Gaffin's understanding of Calvin's view of the Sabbath and shown most effectively that John Calvin held to the same view of the Sabbath/Fourth Commandment as the Puritans which is firmly grounded in the Scriptures.

So, there you have a summary of the controversy in a nutshell.

That's the bottom line, isn't it?

(Besides, I thought it was Martin Luther who was the bowler. . .

Thanks to all who have contributed to this thread.My church is in the midst of a study of the LBCF on Sunday nights.Next week we take up the chapter concerning the Sabbath.With all that I have gleaned from this site I think that I am now well prepared.
This is the very reason that I would continue to encourage each one to contribute so that we might have a resource such as we now do.