Quote
OrthodoxCatholic said:
The scriptural precedent is the promise of Christ to St. Peter that the Church would not be overrun by the gates of hell. The only way this would be possible is to have an infallible leader -- a covenantal head if you please -- over the Church to guide Her into all truth. Then there was also the promise made to the apostles in the Upper Room where Jesus promised them that the Holy Spirit would guide them into all truth.
O' contrare.... see here: Argument for an Infallible Body.

Your other claim:


"The Catholic Faith is that which has been believed by all persons, in every place, at all times"

Sorry, the only two faiths which can claim this are the Eastern Orthodox and the 26 rites of the Catholic Church.



is so ridiculously contrary to all known history that it isn't worth the time to reply. There are so many differences in doctrine and/or practice that have existed in the "Catholic" church, both Roman and Orthodox, that it staggers the imagination how anyone can make such a claim, although many have and still do. All it would take to disprove such a boastful remark is to show but one single dissenter. The fact that there have been thousands is but icing on the cake.

In His Grace,

[Linked Image]

simul iustus et peccator

[Linked Image]