Pilgrim said: "DeYoung's criticism of Lewis' view of the atonement is what I am mainly wanting to address. His criticism of Lewis' error(s) concerning the atonement is NOT correct because he faults Lewis for not being agreement with his own faulty view. Yes, Lewis' view of the atonement is woefully wrong and so is DeYoung's view. Sooooo, someone could easily read that section and believe that DeYoung's view of...

Thus, that is why I asked you to critique DeYoung's statement(s) on the atonement in his criticism of Lewis, which thus far has been ignored. It would be most helpful for you to do so and put your thoughts here so that many others can benefit from them and/or the exchange that might ensue thereafter. grin"

Pilgrim
What you appear to be saying here (at least to me) is that DeYoung believes in Penal Substitutional Atonement which you believe is not biblical.
That is where my confusion is.
You seem to want me to critique a position that I agree with.
Tom

Last edited by Tom; Mon Dec 28, 2015 1:50 PM.