The Highway Forums General Discussion Theology Discussion Forum What happens to the unborn dead ?

Just curious if anyone here is familiar with Ronald Nash's book When a Baby Dies, or John MacArthur's Safe in the Arms of God? I understand that the view advocated in these books was also embraced by Charles Hodge, B. B. Warfield, John Newton, Augustus Toplady, and Charles Spurgeon (I'm sure there are others as well). Among Reformed Baptists, John Piper and Al Mohler also hold this view. I would like to know what the chief criticisms of this position are, especially since everyone here appears to believe that some infants are elect and others are not.