J Edwards

I point out that ‘charismatic’ is a term loaded with Biblical theology in case you were using quotes from someone who termed the prophets of Canaan ‘charismatic’ as a polemic against those who used the term.

You also wrote,
Quote
In 1 Corinthians 12, Paul warned against the charismatic practice of the pagans


The term ‘charismatic’ comes from a Greek word used in relation to grace. The practices of the pagans might be termed ‘pneumatic’ but ‘charismatic’ should be seen as a word with positive connotations, since it has to do with the grace gifts of God, and not the spiritual practices of the pagans. That does not mean that everything that gets called ‘Charismatic’ is truly charismatic.